April 27, 2017 - Dion Caputi
Caputi: Pick-By-Pick Analysis (Round 1)
Settle in, I'm here to accompany you through the 2017 NFL Draft's first day of selections. Here you'll find my pick-by-pick analysis as we progress through the night. Have a comment for me? Hit me up on Twitter: @NFLDraftUpdate 1. Cleveland Browns: Myles Garrett, DE. Texas A&M The right pick for a franchise lacking a genuine premier cornerstone on defense for far too long. This situation reminds me so much of Mario Williams' selection by Houston in 2006. Defensive end has become a true value position over the past half-decade and good teams require elite edge play. Myles Garrett will have bare the flag of the Cleveland revolution, but fortunately he has a ton of talent supporting his efforts. 2. Chicago Bears (via SF): Mitchell Trubisky, QB. North Carolina - *TRADE Let the games begin. Cleveland consciously passed on Trubisky at No. 1 knowing it was impossible he'd be available to them again. Oh, and don't forget about John Lynch's San Francisco 49ers already making a bold move by allowing the Bears to select the potential franchise arm - acquiring a boatload for the one draft spot in the process, I'll add. Only two picks in and already we have a major storyline to follow in the coming years. Browns and 49ers pass on Trubisky: will they find their QBs later? will Trubisky pan out? Time will tell. *Details of trade To Bears: 1st round pick (No. 2 - Trubisky) To 49ers: 1st round pick (No. 3), 3rd round pick (No. 67), 4th round pick (No. 111) + 2018 3rd round pick 3. San Francisco 49ers (via CHI): Solomon Thomas, DE. Stanford John Lynch goes to his alma mater for his first pick as a General Manager. Building the defense from the ground up after making Thomas the franchise's third 1st round defensive lineman selection in as many years (previous Arik Armstead, 2015 and DeForest Buckner, 2016). He's not a tweener, he's versatile. Hand in the dirt on 4-3 looks or rushing off the edge in a two-point stance on 3-4 downs, he can change the complexion of games. 4. Jacksonville Jaguars: Leonard Fournette, RB. Louisiana State Elite size to speed ration with an undeniable mean streak. Ultimately, this pick had to be made in support of Blake Bortles and the Jags' minimalist ground game. T.J. Yeldon is a nice player, but Fournette adds an element that simply wasn't there before this evening. 5. Tennessee Titans: Corey Davis, WR. Western Michigan A more complete, all-around receiver than guys perceivably graded ahead of him, but finds the right "fit" for your offense trumps the public's draft board. Davis is tremendously productive + experienced, enters the league with a ton of polish and adds a more imposing physical element to Mariota's arsenal. 6. New York Jets: Jamal Adams, S. Louisiana State Whether the organization realizes it or not, there is a rebuild going on right now and Adams' tone-setting abilities are a timely addition. Though the needs on defense were greater elsewhere, the Jets front office were not expecting this scenario - too much talent to pass on. Great pick - my favorite thus far. 7. Los Angeles Chargers: Mike Williams, WR. Clemson The wide receiver need was always evident, but to get their guy this early is surprising when you consider the talent available on defense. That said, Phil Rivers ain't getting younger and he's never been able to rely on Keenan Allen to be healthy for a full 16 games. Williams is the best 50-50 receiver in this draft and adds an element that was sorely missing in the pass game. 8. Carolina Panthers: Christian McCaffrey, RB/WR. Stanford Four-down player, don't put him in a box as just being a running back. You want to allow him 20-30 touches and create opportunities for him in space, as he offers pretty scary open-field elusiveness. Can you imagine the possibilities of a Cam Newton + Christian McCaffrey backfield? Sign me up for some college-style options looks once in a while - they could be special together. Caf's special teams ability is just the cherry on top. 9. Cincinnati Bengals: John Ross, WR. Washington The fastest man in NFL Combine history is off to Cincy. The Bengals are fortunate that the one receiver who suits their offense best in this receiver group fell to them. Ross' speed creates a dangerous over-the-top threat that should relieve AJ Green of some pesky double-coverages. Calling Ross a similar player to DeSean Jackson would be miscasting him - at minimum, he enters the NFL running B+ routes with A++ speed. 10. Kansas City Chiefs (via BUF): Pat Mahomes, QB. Texas Tech - *TRADE The biggest talent at his position in the class and he's entering the ideal situation where he can sit for a complete season before worrying about meaningful snaps. We thought all along that he had a hard-stop at No. 12-13 with the quarterback-hungry Browns and Cardinals soon on the clock. He creates his own opportunities and is equipped with an A++ arm. In 3-5 years, we may look back at the quarterback order and say this situation worked out the best. *Details of trade To Chiefs: 1st round pick (No. 10 - Mahomes), To Bills: 1st round pick (No. 27), 3rd round pick (No. 91) + 2018 1st round pick. 11. New Orleans Saints: Marshon Lattimore, CB. Ohio State The Saints front office, much like the viewing public, could never have imagined Lattimore would be available outside of the top ten. You must think his constant hamstring issue may have at least mildly contributed to this happening, but the cornerback-starved Saints are thrilled by the opportunity to roll the dice here. 12. Houston Texans (via CLE): DeShaun Watson, QB. Clemson - *TRADE It's well-documented that Bill O'Brien is a fan of the big, strong prototype passers. DeShaun Watson doesn't quite fit that profile and it just goes to show how highly O'Brien must rate his intangibles. An accurate passer who comes alive in big moments, Watson is the safest quarterback in this class and he's joining a playoff team. Houston went to the playoffs despite receiving marginal QB play last year, so the pressure isn't on Watson to be a world-beater in year one. *Details of trade To Texans: 1st round pick (No. 12 - Watson), To Browns: 1st round pick (No. 25) + 2018 1st round pick. 13. Arizona Cardinals: Haasan Reddick, LB. Temple Cards missed out on landing a QB to create the ideal redshirt scenario they desired, but might have landed the best realistic player on their board otherwise. Reddick is a self-starter, improving annually and holds genuine 2-3 position versatility. Will help wherever needed and contribute as a pass rusher from day one. 14. Philadelphia Eagles: Derek Barnett, DE. Tennessee This one made a lot of sense pre-draft. Marcus Smith hasn't panned out and Philly required a more reliable option off the edge behind Brandon Graham. Three consistent years of sack production at Tennessee, I don't care if the combine numbers weren't eye-popping on him, he gets after it. 15. Indianapolis Colts: Malik Hooker, S. Ohio State Boom or bust poster boy from this draft class. Hooker has only one year of production, but it was absurdly productive. Elite center-field type with excellent ball skills. Sideline to sideline range and near-cornerback caliber movement skills, but the inexperience and durability concerns must be noted. Will he show flashes of Ed Reed at the next level or are we talking Raheem Moore 2.0? I'm suspect there won't be much in-between with him. Tremendous potential-based pick. 16. Baltimore Ravens: Marlon Humphrey, CB. Alabama Ozzie Newsome drafts a player from Alabama? No way! Seriously, this is a bargain pickup here as Humphrey could have easily gone to New Orleans had Lattimore not been available as expected. A physical press-man type, he profiles somewhat like Pro-Bowler Stephon Gilmore stylistically. Makes you wonder about Jonathan Allen though - if Ozzie wasn't even comfortable scooping him 17. Washington Redskins: Jonathan Allen, DL. Alabama While the arthritic shoulder situation is worrisome, the Redskins have glaring issues along their 3-4 base defensive line. Strictly from a talent standpoint, Allen is a top 3 player in this class and worth the risk here for Washington. The Skins' trench play has already improved with this selection. 18. Tennessee Titans: Adoree Jackson, CB. Southern California This pick was (hopefully) made with patience in mind. As the diminutive playmaker develops as a corner I do hope to see him contribute immediately as an ace returner and hopefully on offense a little. Size and matchup length aren't mandatory physical traits in Tennessee, nor have they ever been. It was always going to take an open-minded team to choose Adoree and the Titans may reap the long-term benefits as a result. 19. Tampa Bay Buccaneers: O.J. Howard, TE. Alabama Great fortune for the Bucs, who continue adding to an enviously impressive core of weaponry for Famous Jameis. Howard represents elite pass-catching potential, but enters the league with polish as a blocker. Hell, he did it so much at Bama, that shouldn't come as a surprise. Either way, massive bargain at this point. 20. Denver Broncos: Garett Bolles, OT. Utah There's no better athlete available along the offensive line in this draft class. Bolles essentially stays home and has long-term left tackle potential, though he requires a bit of polishing - which should come at RT. In a rather weak OL draft overall I think Elway & Co. go the potential route. Bolles is a mean dude on-field and enjoys a good trench battle. 21. Detroit Lions: Jarrad Davis, ILB. Florida Rangy interior linebacker to the team who was most desperate for help in that spot in the league. Davis is a leader by example, modern in style and provides a major athletic boost to the Lions' linebacking core. Conventional thinking says there was just no way Reuben Foster would be available here though. For them to pass on him says quite a bit about what kind of slide Foster might be in for tonight and/or tomorrow. 22. Miami Dolphins: Charles Harris, DE. Missouri A coaches dream, Harris is a self-starter who has had to earn his time at Missouri behind a conveyer belt of strong collegiate edge defenders. After two productive starting seasons, I'm happy to see him land with a 4-3 team as I believe 4-3 end is his ideal situation. To Miami, he's Cam Wake's heir apparent. 23. New York Giants: Evan Engram, TE. Ole Miss All along, it was a very strong possibility that Engram could go ahead of David Njoku. His skill-set appeals to more teams, including those who already had an entrenched tight end. The reason is he's not a true tight end, nor is he a wide receiver - though versatile nonetheless. Eli obtains a field-stretcher. 24. Oakland Raiders: Gareon Conley, CB. Ohio State Simply put, if the off-field allegations didn't happen, he's comfortably a top 15 pick. Give the Raiders front office the benefit of the and assume they know something the public doesn't, because there still appears to be some uncertainty here. That said, on-field, this is a fantastic all-around player who contributes day one. Oakland entered this draft lacking a solution at corner opposite Sean Smith. We'll see how this one plays out. 25. Cleveland Browns (via HOU): Jabrill Peppers, S/LB. Michigan - *TRADE His personality should certainly help to provide a spark in a stagnant Browns locker room. Hue Jackson is attempting to change the culture of the organization's on-field product and you do that by collecting players like Peppers. Though, to me, he's more of a tweener than he is versatile I'll assume the team selecting him is doing so with a specific role in mind for him. 26. Atlanta Falcons (via SEA): Takkarist McKinley, DE/OLB. UCLA - *TRADE Relentless motor off the edge either as a 4-3 end or standup edge linebacker. Offers some role diversity for the Falcons' pass rushing setups and increases the 'compete' level of an already strong defensive core. By the way - who didn't love that on-stage moment? You've just got to love live TV. Good for him - as he's certainly not going to enter the NFL lacking in motivation. *Details of trade To Falcons: 1st round pick (No. 26 - McKinley), To Seahawks: 1st round pick (No. 31), 3rd round pick (No. 95), 7th round pick (No. 249). 27. Buffalo Bills (via KC): Tre'Davious White, CB. Louisiana State - *TRADE 4-year starter who should make a seamless transition into a starting role from day one and competent enough to contribute in a multitude of roles in coverage. Stephon Gilmore departed and reinforcements were needed asap. Nice to see Buffalo think big-picture and acquire a 2018 1st round selection while still crossing off a considerable roster hole. 28. Dallas Cowboys: Taco Charlton, DE. Michigan Long disruptive figure who feasted in opposing backfields. That said, he's a one-year wonder, but the Cowboys are clearly pleased with the upside aspect of this pick. Despite his size + frame, Taco gets real-real skinny. Dallas has some talent on the edges, but these days teams require 3-4 viable options. I like this pick, Taco is too talented to have slid out of day one. 29. Cleveland Browns (via GB): David Njoku, TE. Miami (FL) - *TRADE Supremely gifted athlete with absolutely no physical limitations. Njoku is still just 20 and enters the league as something of a diamond in the rough, as his catching is a little inconsistent for my liking. However, when he's your third 1st round pick, than I think you feel comfortable rolling the dice on his talent. If you pass on all of the quarterbacks, at least help Kessler. They did with this pick. 30. Pittsburgh Steelers: T.J. Watt, OLB. Wisconsin Can't draw it up any better. Energy, toughness, attitude - all ideal characteristics Pittsburgh seeks on defense, all adjectives of T.J. Watt. One of the more complete defenders available at this point and it's logical that he proved too talented to slip out of day one. Steelers have been trying to get younger on D for years. 31. San Francisco 49ers (via ATL by SEA): Reuben Foster, ILB. Alabama - *TRADE We'll assume this slide - like teammate Jonathan Allen's - was medical related, but I applaud rookie GM John Lynch for being aggressive at both the top and bottom of round 1. Thomas and Foster help frame a new attitude for a rebuilding San Francisco defense that was very good not long ago. *Details of trade To 49ers: 1st round pick (No. 31 - Foster), To Packers: 2nd round pick (No. 33), 4th round pick (No. 108). 32. New Orleans Saints (via NE): Ryan Ramczyk, OT. Wisconsin Plug and play right tackle to help keep the grizzled Drew Brees upright. Saints addressed the big cornerback need earlier and now knock off arguably the second largest hole on the roster. Unsexy, but sound pick to conclude the day.